Fire chief Tony McGuirk's "drivel" email blunder

By David Bartlett on Aug 25, 09 12:40 PM in

tony_mcguirk.jpg

Merseyside's Chief Fire Office Tony McGuirk has committed one of those email blunders that happens to us all at some point.

Today we report how he ended up forwarding, what was supposed to be a private response to a councillor, to a former member of staff making a complaint about the way the sacking of an officer had been dealt with.

Mally Swann - who retired five years ago after a 30-year career - emailed a Fire Authority member saying he thought the service overreacted by sacking Mr Hughes.

The councillor apparently forwarded Mr Swann's email to CFO McGuirk asking for advice about how to reply.

But in a private comment, also sent to Mr Swann, the chief said: "Malcolm is a very long serving union official and activist who retired a while ago and this sort of outpouring of drivel is pretty typical stuff.

"Why let facts get in the way of a good old whine!! He is clearly wrong in his understanding but we will not be commenting on this matter because Mr Hughes is in the middle of an appeal process and it would be inappropriate to comment."

CFO McGuirk also suggested warning Mr Swann persistent emailing could be a criminal offence.

This raises a wider issue as well though. Is it right for a councillor to email the chief officer to ask for his opinion on a matter like this?

Councillors are supposed to be on the Fire Authority to scrutinise chief fire officers like Mr McGuirk not just ask for their opinions on the matter of the day.

8 Comments

John Cleaver said:

I think that CFO McGuirk should stand up and say this to Mr Swann himself. Mr McQuirck obviously likes to hide behind council officials. Emailing a councilor is not a criminal offence! When a Councillor forwards a fire representative this is a breach of data protection. CFO McGuirk needs to understand what a criminal offense regarding emailing is. Emailing a Councillor is not a criminal offense a Councillor forwarding an email is! CFO McGuirk needs to gets his facts straight! TOOL!

Magnificent goods from you, man. I've understand your stuff previous to and you're just too excellent.

I really like what you have acquired here, certainly
like what you're stating and the way in which you say it. You make it entertaining and you still care for to keep it sensible. I can't wait to read
far more from you. This is actually a great web site.

「トリーバーチ」世界ではすでに400店舗以上!ものすごい勢いですね。

例えば、文字を書くときにペン先寄りで持つ傾向のある人は、筆圧が強めで細字を好むタイプが多いようですね。

モノグラムと悩みましたが、モノグラムはやっぱりヌメ革の染みや汚れがだんだん気になってくるので、汚れの目立たないダミエにしましたo(^-^)o

インクが切れてしまった場合、販売店舗・専門店などに替え芯やカートリッジ等は置いてあると思われるので、自分で交換することも覚えておきましょう。

黒のキャディバックを購入しました。デザインが上品で落ち着きがあります。フードが固めでかたくづれしません。

WONDERFUL Post.thanks for share..more wait .. ?

Leave a comment


Type the characters you see in the picture above.

This is to help prevent spamming and confirm you are a human

 

Dale Street Associates

David Bartlett

David Bartlett

City editor of the Post and Echo covering politics, regeneration, and urban affairs.
Read My Posts »

Follow us on Twitter

SPONSORED LINKS