Liverpool Wavertree MP Luciana Berger's maiden speech

By David Bartlett on Jun 3, 10 09:09 AM in

luciana_berger450.jpgLiverpool Wavertree MP Luciana Berger has used her maiden speech to call on the Tories to honour their pledge to build a new Royal Liverpool Hospital.

In a well researched speech Miss Berger also told the House of Commons of many notable successes and famous people from Wavertree.

She paid tribute to outgoing Wavertree MP Jane Kennedy quoted Nye Bevan and her great-uncle Manny Shinwell in the speech that was described as "wonderful" by Deputy Speaker Hugh Bayley.

Below is Miss Berger's entire speech:

I congratulate the hon. Member for Stroud (Neil Carmichael) and all those who made their fascinating maiden speeches that we have heard in this debate. It has been a real education. I thank you, Mr Deputy Speaker, for allowing me the opportunity to make my maiden speech in this debate. In his book "In Place of Fear", Nye Bevan wrote of the frustration caused to new MPs who provocatively deliver the concerns of their constituents in their maiden speeches and are met simply by a polite response from the next speaker, according to parliamentary convention:

"After remaining in his seat a little longer, the new Member crawls out of the House with feelings of deep relief at having got it over with, mingled with a paralysing sense of frustration. The stone he thought he had thrown turned out to be a sponge."

Notwithstanding parliamentary tradition, I shall endeavour to make my points provocatively, and to receive equally strong, uncompromising answers from Members opposite in due course.

I succeed the right hon. Jane Kennedy, an inspirational lady who served our nation and the people of Liverpool, Wavertree-formerly the constituency of Liverpool, Broadgreen-for nearly 20 years. She worked tirelessly for her constituents and was also a Minister in no fewer than six Departments. Her time as security Minister in Northern Ireland was precious to her. Jane was incredibly proud that it was the Labour Government who made such strides against the scourge of youth unemployment. When Jane was Minister for Work, there was virtually no youth unemployment, and serving as Health Minister, Jane was also so proud of the improvements made to our NHS under the previous Labour Government, particularly as they affected older constituents.

Jane did what so many could not or would not. I was struck by the number of people I met on Wavertree's doorsteps who admired her greatly for the courageous actions that she took, particularly for her stance against the militant tendency. A brave woman, she will always remain an inspiration-never afraid to roll up her sleeves and get stuck in, even at the highest levels of Government. Jane did a sterling job for her constituents, for the Labour Government and in this House. As my friend and mentor, I hope to do her proud.

I have the privilege of representing the warm and kind people of Liverpool, Wavertree. It is a remarkably mixed constituency-culturally and historically rich, and ethnically diverse. It is a mixture of suburbia and metropolis, and a place where the old meets the new. We have our fair share of notable residents and landmarks from across the business, academic, musical, religious and political worlds. Wavertree is the birthplace of Meccano, Littlewoods pools and catalogue shopping. It is also home to the oldest Hindu community in the UK outside London.

Perhaps our most famous residents were John Lennon and George Harrison; Penny lane sits on the border of the constituency. Some lesser known people also deserve mention for the contribution they have made, not only to local life but also nationally. Dr Fred Freeman was a Wavertree businessman who owned a large department store in the constituency; he was also the philanthropist who pioneered tax-effective giving in the UK. James Newlands, a resident of Edge Hill, became the first borough engineer for Liverpool in 1847 and paved the way for municipal engineering as the world knows it today, creating the world's first integrated sewerage system. The significance of that development cannot be overrated. During his years in office, Newlands succeeded in doubling the average life expectancy from 19 to 38.

Politically, the constituency has seen a whole spectrum of political representation. The new hon. Member for Suffolk Coastal (Dr Coffey) went to school in the constituency, as did Edwina Currie. Lord Alton was once its Member of Parliament and Derek Hatton lived in Childwall. Although Wavertree has been home to notable political representatives from across the political divide, it is the rich Labour witness within the constituency that has made such an impact. Stewart Headlam, one of the pioneers and publicists of Christian socialism, was born in Wavertree, and fiery campaigner "Battling Bessie" Braddock attended a Socialist Sunday school in Marmaduke street in the constituency. I intend to keep the rich socialist tradition alive.

We will be celebrating two notable anniversaries in Wavertree this year. In 1836 the world's oldest passenger station, described by some historians as the start of the modern world, opened in Edge Hill, and this September marks the 180th anniversary of the opening of the Liverpool to Manchester railway line, which started at Edge Hill station. That was the first time anyone in the world could travel between two cities by rail. This celebration will be taking place at Metal, a creative hub that sits in the station today. We are also marking the 100-year anniversary of the Wavertree garden suburb, a development that was part of a national movement to improve urban living conditions, which gave tenants a stake in the place where they lived.

I requested the opportunity to make my maiden speech during the education and health debate because knowledge and well-being are so important to my constituents. I urge the right hon. Member for South Cambridgeshire (Mr Lansley) to honour the guarantee that he made in March to rebuild the Royal Liverpool hospital. The scheme is so important, not only to sustain the provision of high-quality health care for all the people of Liverpool, including many in my constituency, but also because it will be the catalyst for sustaining growth in the economic renaissance of Liverpool, with the creation of a globally excellent, biomedical science campus.

Similarly, as highlighted by my hon. Friend the Member for Liverpool, West Derby (Stephen Twigg), Alder Hey-the largest national children's hospital in Europe, which treats young people from more than 85% of the UK's PCTs-must see its accommodation upgraded. Alder Hey has put forward the most affordable hospital scheme in the country to replace its Florence Nightingale design from 100 years ago, so it can provide paediatric treatment in 21st-century facilities.

As a Labour and Co-operative MP, I am delighted that there have been real strides to expand mutualism in our public services. Mutualism ensures the promotion of democratic accountability-giving users, staff and other stakeholders a real say in how our public services are run. So far, the biggest expansion of mutuality has taken place in the NHS, with the formation of 129 NHS foundation trusts, which are accountable to a widely defined membership of more than 1.5 million. Similarly, in social care 178 user-led organisations have been created, and they both design and deliver high-quality services.

I move on to education. Incredible investment has been made into my constituency, where we have made great strides in education. Before the right hon. Member for Surrey Heath (Michael Gove) starts redirecting money from the education budget to create new free schools, I urge him to come and see how education is working in Liverpool. I urge him to invest in those schools, such as St Hilda's in Picton and Archbishop Blanch School in Wavertree, that already have a vibrant community ethos and active governing bodies, and are already achieving above national-average grades at GCSE.

Nearly 90 years ago, my great-uncle, Manny Shinwell, newly elected as the Member for Linlithgowshire, made his maiden speech to this House. It feels almost eerie now to echo the words that he said then, that

"in opposition we would bring every kind of pressure-constitutional pressure, I may say-to bear on the Government in order to compel the Government to implement the pledges they gave".

23 Comments

Ronnie de Ramper said:

Luciana will make an outstanding and long-serving MP. There has never been any doubt of that. All the self-promoting old men who queued up to criticise her, can now queue up to apologise. Step forward and line up: Peter Kilfoyle, Phil Redmond, Ricky Tomlinson for starters.

Bergerwatcher said:

"Well-researched?". Peter Dowling must still be on the payroll then. Since when has St Hilda's been in Picton or Archbishop Blanche in Wavertree? More to the point, has she resigned as Director of Labour Friends of Isreal yet, as promised?

Friend of everyone said:

This obsession with Labour Friends of Israel amongst some people ignores the fact that there is a Lib Dem Friends of Israel and a Conservative Friends of Israel who are committed to generally the same ideals as Labour's version.

Considering the fact that the Con Dems are now in Govt together, should we not focus on them now - or are the mysoginistic attacks on Ellman, Berger and Kennedy set to continue?

As for this maiden speech - though cut short I thought it a good promotion of the city and Wavertree and am very pleased it was Miss Berger making it and not the bumbling fool that the Lib Dems put forward. He would have had to explain away his initial opposition to the Alder Hey proposals first.

Bergerwatcher said:

It was a pedestrian maiden speech - she couldn't even get the locations of the schools right. So much for "listening to her constituents". More seriously, David Cameron described himself as a "Friend of Isreal" yesterday, yet denounced the miltary attack on the flotilla and implored the Isreal Govt. to stop the barricade of humanitarian aid. Will Ms Berger do the same or is she still a Director?

smart alec reporter said:

No mention of Bill Shankly, Gerry Marsden or the Mersey Tunnels though...

Dance Beats said:

I have kind of a diffrent outlooks on this article. I agree with the author but some points I have diffrent views on.

Louise Baldock said:

The point about the two schools that Luciana talked about is not where they are currently located but that if BSF goes ahead they will be moving to the Littlewoods site which is in the constituency. What she was clearly doing was asking the ConDem Government to honour the commitment the Labour one made to building these two new schools. It is petty in the extreme to ignore everything else she said and to focus on this. In point of fact neither school is in her constituency at the moment, so why should she know their addresses? Clearly she is working hard to ensure that they get the new facilities they need - which WILL be in Wavertree. Good for her!

I think it was a great speech.

come on now said:

But she does not suggest it is about where they WILL be but where they are - and she singularly failed to identify that. She has got it wrong.

Her speech was good though it was clearly cut short. But she should not have got the detail wrong - it is important that our MP's are on top of the detail. For someone who was exposed for her lack of local knowledge it is especially important.

So don't try and gloss over this and don't suggest that it does not matter - if it were Eldridge you would have slammed him. She did well but she should have known better.

Louise Baldock said:

Is ABB in Wavertree or Riverside?
It is on the border, on Mount Vernon next to Smithdown Lane, is that Picton ward or Central ward? How few metres is it, either within or without the boundary? I dont know, without going off to ask someone, and I am Vice Chair of the CLP.

St Hilda's is in Greenbank ward I think, but only a quarter of a mile at most from the Picton border on Smithdown Road, or the Church border on Penny Lane, both of which are in Wavertree.

So, when you say she singularly failed, you are being pedantic.

I think detail does matter, but what was important was that she highlighed the need for the ConDems to invest in these two schools - through BSF - and build new schools for each, on the Littlewoods site.

If you think that the voters are going to be annoyed because she failed to identify which side of Smithdown Lane the parliamentary boundary runs, then I think you have missed the point. Luciana spoke well and with passion about her constituency and about her hopes for the future. She did us proud.

That is not to say that if she find herself in a position to employ a researcher, she wont be in an even stronger position, but she wrote this herself and I think it was extremely creditable.

mrsgilliansmith said:

OMG ! Pass the sick bucket ! Berger is a pedestrian nonentity who knows little about Liverpool and shows no aptitude for learning. By the way, isn't it about time someone advised her on her dress sense

Tom Morrison said:

Does anyone actually care two hoots about the speech she made?

I did see it and I actually thought she did okay, it wasn't brilliant, but she passed.

I don't think slating her for her maiden speech is going to paint anyone in a good picture.

However I am interested in why none of the other Labour MPs have had their maiden speeches reported... I'm guessing David just wanted to stir a reaction and it seems some people fell for it hook, line and sinker..

Lets move on to 2011 now shall we?

Hi Tom,
Contrary to trying to cause a stir I wasn't aware of the other's maiden speeches, it takes a while to get through them all. I'm happy to stand corrected though. Maybe I should have had a vote on best maiden speech when they were all done?

Ronnie de Ramper said:

Does anyone care two hoots about anything Tom Morrison says? This is a burnt-out agent of a washed-up candidate, a person responsible for relentlessly misogynistic and personalised attacks on Luciana Berger and others, rejected by fair-minded people and clearly now stewing in his own bile. He is a fitting member of a LibDem group that condoned the criminal Steve Hurst, and now counts as his colleague the disgusting Sharon Green.

Tom Morrison said:

Burned out at such an early age as well. Tragic.

Perhaps you want to use your real name so we can talk like adults?

If you read my above post "Ronnie" then you'll find I was actually supporting Luciana Berger, not attacking her.

As for attacks, are you condoning the highly personal attacks that both myself and Colin had to face from the Labour campaign?

Wind your neck in.

Tom

dave partridge said:

Tom

fyi ive seen and heard the maiden speeches of two new local Labour mps quoted Alison McGovern and Bill Esterson both on radio and on the parliament channel- quite why the echo hasnt mentioned them is for them to tell us - but didnt you say on your blog recently that you were so disgusted with the local rag that you were never going to read it again - surely you havent done a u turn that quickly

and your comment on the blog about Miss Berger not making as good an MP as Eldridge would have done - bitter and silly blind loyalty - give up fighting the election - Eldridge lost in a seat you were expected to win and managed a 5 per cent swing to Labour - ask yourself this , how in the 6 council wards of the parliamentary seat of Wavertree did nearly 15000 vote LD but only 12965 voted for Eldridge - He shouldnt stand again - certainly not in Wavertree

and finally why are the Liberals defending Laws so much - even he admitted he was wrong - his conduct was atrocious in a number of ways and his relish to inflict the financial pain obscene- Parliament never mind the government would look a lot better without someone of his hubris

Tom said:

I'm not sure I mentioned reading the Echo in my above post... but thanks for reading Dave.

As for David Laws, I think it was actually a good move for him to stand down while he is being investigated.. an investigation I may add, that he put himself up for.

How many Labour and Tory politicians did the same when the expenses scandal hit?

Tom

P.S. Stephen Twigg has also made his maiden speech. (I guess it's still counted as maiden even though he's been their before)

dave partridge said:

Sorry Tom i cant let you away with that one

Laws referring himself to the standards commissioner is not that noble a gesture , and there were quite a few MPs who did it , 2 who come to mind straight away are Shahid Malik and David Chaytor both from the Labour Benches- neither of course now in the commons .

its a device to buy time and Laws is playing the system - in his own words , " i accept that there was something wrong " - why cant you LDs condemn him - and that is the appropriate term for a clear breach of the rules and taking public funds he was not entitled to.- If Clegg had anything about him he'd tell him he wont stand in Yeovil next time - but i somehow doubt he'll do that.

Tom said:

Ever heard of innocent until proven guilty?

The irony is that if David had declared his relationship he then could have claimed more in expenses legally.

Look I'm not condoning what David Laws did, he even knew it was wrong. But the party, including Nick Clegg are waiting for the standards commission to report back before any judgement is made.

We're not rushing into a knee jerk reaction.

I still stand by my original point though. No other cabinet minister in the previous administration stood down during the expenses scandal. David Laws did.

That says alot and which is why the public mood seems more forgiving about him.

mrsgilliansmith said:

The hypocrisy of Labourites never ceases to astound me. Here they are going on about David Laws, there they were making disgusting allegations against Colin Eldridge prior to the election, and now we have...wait for it !..

City and North magazine reporting that Joe Anderson "plans to take on the role (as city council leader) full time".

Sounds like hard pressed council tax payers are about to stump up at least the fifty grand a year he was demanding to be paid for the job !

Les Hughes said:

In reply to Tom Morrison: The other new Liverpool MP-Steve Rotheram-has yet to make his maiden speech. Stephen Twigg made a speech on the same night as Luciana, bur it was not his maiden speech- he famously beat Portillo in 1997- or maybe you were not allowed to stay up late then?

Tom Morrison said:

Les, classic dig at my age.. well done there.

I did stay up late then, in fact I kept my tv on really quiet so my mum wouldn't know it was on. I had a science exam the day after you see.

I remember it well for two reasons.

Firstly Twigg beat Portillo.. amazing stuff. From what I heard he wasn't expected to win either? Stephen Twigg is an awesome campaigner and he proved it there and then.

Secondly, that night, sadly, was supposed to be a dawn of a new era. A fantastic new voyage into a new century with a party that walked the walk as well as talked the talk when it came to tackling poverty and cutting down on sleaze.

I used the term sadly because it was all so easily forgotten and the hubris set in.

That's why I left the Labour party and that's why I'll never, ever forgive them for turning their back on the people they were supposed to care about.

In the meantime, we've had wise cracks about my age and about me being a "washed up agent".. anyone else want to try and make me cry?

The Orange Book off said:

Seems that Tom left the Labour Party because it wasn't economicaly liberal enough! No doubt he will sit listening to the incorrect claims of the economically illiterate members of his local party claim they are the social democrats. Laughable.

The Lib Dems with Clegg and Cable were taken over by their "militant" right wing many years ago so no wonder they feel at home with the Tories and their cuts agenda (what changed between May 6th and May 12th for the Lib Dems to renounce the need for investment now as Keynsianism suggests?)

Perhaps Tom will give his maiden speech on the virtues of the decidedly right-wing free market economic policies the Orange Book promoted or will he keep that one quiet? I suspect the latter.

Leave a comment


Type the characters you see in the picture above.

This is to help prevent spamming and confirm you are a human

 

Dale Street Associates

David Bartlett

David Bartlett

City editor of the Post and Echo covering politics, regeneration, and urban affairs.
Read My Posts »

Follow us on Twitter

SPONSORED LINKS