Guest blog: Paul Clein reflects on losing his seat on Liverpool council and returning to 'conventional life'
I spent about one third of my life (so far) as a member of Liverpool City Council until I lost my Greenbank seat on May 5th.
From 1984 onwards, I had resisted regular invitations to become directly involved in local politics. Four years as a parent governor at my children's primary school convinced me otherwise. I concluded that getting elected was the best means to try to effect positive change in the City's Education Service which was a low priority for the Council's then Labour administration.
I joined the Liberal Democrats in 1991 and was a successful candidate the following year. I believe I was a dedicated, proactive and conscientious ward Councillor and that my defeat in 2011 had nothing to do with me personally nor was it any reflection on the job I did. The voters in Liverpool were understandably angry at the coalition government and acted accordingly.
I am now in the process of returning to a more conventional way of life. During my 19 year term of office, I usually worked an average 3 days per week as a self-employed locum pharmacist and I now intend to do this on a more full time basis. I know I am in a more fortunate position than some of my erstwhile colleagues who were, in effect, full time Councillors. Some lost their seats and became unemployed. Unlike MPs in a similar position, there are no parachute payments or any other assistance for losing Councillors.
It has been touching to have so many enquiring about my wellbeing since the election, including a surprisingly sizable number of Labour Councillors. Despite most people's expectations to the contrary, I actually feel liberated, not least because I had anticipated losing for several months beforehand and had prepared myself psychologically. I feel like I now have my life back. Being a Council member can be an all-consuming way of life. It certainly was for me.
In future also (and this is not an exhaustive list):
· I will have my Tuesday nights back (no more weekly advice surgeries);
· I will no longer have to plan all holidays and time off around scheduled Council and Committee meetings. I will now be able to have more than two weeks leave if I choose (every year since 1992 except one, Jan and I had zero, one or two weeks off);
· I can now work as a pharmacist on Wednesdays and Fridays, which I hardly ever did when a Councillor as I usually kept at least those two days free each week for Council business;
· No more evenings going straight from work to attend residents meetings in draughty halls, followed by dinner at 9.30 or 10pm;
· I will be able to see our three children, family members and friends more often;
· I will be able to go to more concerts and football matches if I wish;
· I can start working my way through the accumulated DVDs, CDs and books which I haven't had time for up to now. I used to read 2 or 3 books a week before I was elected. Since 1992 it's been more like 2 or 3 a year because of the myriad reports that I had to read and digest the contents of. (I was congenitally unable to go into a meeting without having read the agenda papers thoroughly.)
· I can start to reclaim our front room which has been largely used to accommodate four filing cabinets and a bookcase of Council related documents, most of which I envisage will end up in the recycling bin in the near future.
It is said that all political careers end in failure. Having achieved pretty much what I set out to achieve in my 10 years as the Council's Education / Children's Services spokesperson between 1998 and 2008, I don't feel like a failure. Apart from the obvious such as improved standards, better school buildings and preventing the 1999 privatisation of the Education Service, I am particularly pleased about the pioneering work done via our successful Schools Parliament, Primary Modern Foreign Languages programme and the Bullying Audit and Anti-Bullying Strategy, all of which I initiated. I was not a one man band of course and could not have achieved anything without the support of my party colleagues and even on occasion the co-operation of our political opponents. I also got to be a prominent member of an administration which transformed our great City for the better in many ways.
As for the future, who knows? I have no current inclination to attempt a return to local politics, nor do I expect to, but one should never say never in politics. As the Chinese say, we are living in interesting times and I believe our society is at risk of becoming very polarised in the next few years, something which could have disproportionate effects on our City. I am always very wary of vested interest, but in the increasingly stark struggle in the UK between capital and labour, like most Liberal Democrats in Liverpool, I know where my sympathies predominantly lie and it isn't with the plutocrats and multinationals.
As I wrote in my election address to my constituents just before the election, whatever the result on May 5th it was a privilege to serve them and our city for 19 years. That remains my view.


Good luck for the future, whatever you decide to do. Glad to see you have an occupation to fall back on as well.
A very interesting read and I echo the comments above, it is even more difficult for those who lose their seats and have no employment to fall back on- highlighting the perils of those who are full-time councillors. I hope that ex-Cllr Clein finds other ways of contributing to public life.
I agree - a good read, from a genuine man.
I don't, however, have any sympathy with 'full-time councillors' many of whom do so because they are retired or unemployed. Some of these Cllrs have never even spoken at a Council meeting!
Many have spoken of you as a good man, and from your column I have no reason to doubt that. But.....
Isn't your wife a councillor for Greenbank?
Surely you will still plan your holidays around council business because Jan Clein will still have to attend?
Surely you will still have a front room full of council papers (and casework) because your wife will still be using it?
Unless you're telling us that Jan Clein won't be continuing her council work in a fit of pique at you losing. In which case, could she please stand down and let someone else who does want to do the work fill her place!
Many have spoken of you as a good man, and from your column I have no reason to doubt that. But.....
Isn't your wife a councillor for Greenbank?
Surely you will still plan your holidays around council business because Jan Clein will still have to attend?
Surely you will still have a front room full of council papers (and casework) because your wife will still be using it?
Unless you're telling us that Jan Clein won't be continuing her council work in a fit of pique at you losing. In which case, could she please stand down and let someone else who does want to do the work fill her place!
Many have spoken of you as a good man, and from your column I have no reason to doubt that. But.....
Isn't your wife a councillor for Greenbank?
Surely you will still plan your holidays around council business because Jan Clein will still have to attend?
Surely you will still have a front room full of council papers (and casework) because your wife will still be using it?
Unless you're telling us that Jan Clein won't be continuing her council work in a fit of pique at you losing. In which case, could she please stand down and let someone else who does want to do the work fill her place!
I'm assuming you must be a civil servant as you submitted this in triplicate.
Jan is still a Greenbank Councillor for at least the next 12 months and will continue to serve her constituents as assisuously as she always has done. She is not my appendage.
I said "start to" precisely because Jan is still a Council member. Our time off was doubly constrained because we were not on the same committees and outside bodies. There is now only one set of dates to contend with. The papers, some of which have already been recycled, were mine, relating primarily to education and Police Authority matters and long dead casework.
Your snide remarks about Jan are unnecessary and unworthy.
I'd take the "Greenbank Resident" more seriously if he or she gave their real name. Is he/she ashamed of their name or their comments? Typical nasty-Labour, hiding behind anonymity. I say nasty-Labour because there are some nice people in the Labour Group - it's only some policies that we don't agree on.
I take my role as a Councillor for Greenbank very seriously and, for information, we haven't had a holiday for several years. As for my attendance at meetings, for which I do not claim expenses (100% attendance record last year), I will continue as I always have done.
If the residents of Greenbank don't want a hard-working Councillor, then that will be their choice, not that of one anonymous internet troll claiming to live in Greenbank.
I'd take the "Greenbank Resident" more seriously if he or she gave their real name. Is he/she ashamed of their name or their comments? Typical nasty-Labour, hiding behind anonymity. I say nasty-Labour because there are some nice people in the Labour Group - it's only some policies that we don't agree on.
I take my role as a Councillor for Greenbank very seriously and, for information, we haven't had a holiday for several years. As for my attendance at meetings, for which I do not claim expenses (100% attendance record last year), I will continue as I always have done.
If the residents of Greenbank don't want a hard-working Councillor, then that will be their choice, not that of one anonymous internet troll claiming to live in Greenbank.